Nope. I said they would not have had as good of careers as they had. It is hard to compare players head to head. Yes, their careers overlapped, but situations are different. You said you didn't think Rodgers would have played well in Favre's era. If you said you don't think he'd put up the same type of numbers he has or that he may have gotten more injured, that I'd agree with...but I see no reason he wouldn't have been the best QB of that era as well. My apologies for omitting the word "as". He wouldn't play as well. That is why I clarified it in follow-up post.