Adam Lind Career: 273/330/463/793 - His OPS by year (300+ PA) goes: 678, 755, 932, 712, 734, 729, 854, 860, 820* - So he had a late resurgence (29-31 years old) but he struggled against lefties. - Currently 32 with viable concern about age regression. Chris Carter Career: 220/313/462/775 - His OPS by year (300+PA): 770, 799, 734 - BA is clearly his biggest problem. Last year, he didn't clear the Mendoza line. - He is 29 this year. - Switching teams with a fresh start and new BA coach might help a bit, but if he can hit 240 this year, it would be a minor miracle (223, 227,199 BA in those three years with 300+ PA). I'd really doubt that Carter is going to be worth much this season for trades. Perhaps next year, if he can hit around 240/330/470 for the next year and a half, someone might buy in on a consistent improvement taking place. But otherwise, there are probably much better options for a team that wants to make the playoffs. My opinion on Lind's low trade return: 1) I have to think that concern over Lind's age and platoon status are what reduced the trade value of an 800+ OPS 1B. 2) I think Sterns probably had the option of one flawed upper level player or three lower level pitchers that were a bit unknown. So he took the chances on three instead of another "same as" type pitcher.