Since the Olympics, I don't recall one "big game" that Sheets has won. What I mean is any late season game with importance or a game where he's been involved in a battle. There have been games that he's won and dominated in, but close games where he is battling with the other pitcher (i.e. Peavy in San Diego), and he or the Brewers have come out victorious, I do not recall. Games where maybe he's not getting the run support, but needs to stay focused in order to avoid giving up the lead or letting it get out of hand I do not recall. Three games this year fit the bill and he failed in all of them -- Dodgers, Padres and Astros last night. Even Sheets admitted to trying to make the perfect pitch in situations like these as he knows the game is close and he needs to be perfect to win. This shows that he does not have the mentality to succeed like a true #1 ace. If your pitching well and you have been getting hitters out, why change your approach to try and make that one perfect pitch? Just keep doing what your doing and focus on getting each individual batter out. If you start to loose some velocity or "stuff," focus on changing up speeds, location and keeping the ball down. I'm sure this is all known by Sheets, but he has been unable to execute in "big games." The Brewers would be wise to take the Sheets money and re-sign Yo and Parra or maybe go after a Lowe or Garland. Sheets has not proven himself to be worthy of the type of money he will command, and with the potential injury risk, it would be money wasted. His stats show he is not pitching that bad, but stats do not show the emotional part of the game. When emotions run high in tight games and games in the second half of the season, Sheets has been unsuccessful. No stat will show it, but observations over his major league career will. It's no different than observing that Turnbow could not handle the pressure of coming in with men on (especially on the road), or watching Bill Hall and Rickie Weeks consistently try to pull outside pitches. Watching a team and it's players for as many years as most of us have, you develope some kind of intuition or gut feeling on what to expect from them, good and bad. This feeling may not always be correct, but it is based on some truths from past observations.