Although I would prefer Duffy and McGehee make the team over Gwynn and Lamb, I would not be too concerned if the team decides to go the other way for the following reasons: 1. The difference between Duffy being on the team vs. Gwynn will likely not make a difference as they would bring similar production as back ups. So why not let Duffy get his licks in down in AAA? He barely played pro ball last year and could use the at bats instead of wasting away on the Brewer bench. If he lights it up in AAA and Gwynn continues to struggle, then call him up and either release Gwynn or trade him. If they both are productive, then one of the two is trade bait. 2. Lamb is struggling, but if he improves at all, he would be a better platoon option at third then Counsell, if Hall struggles again, and he would be a good pinch hit option due to his experience (preparation makes a good pinch hitter and he some experience with that). 3. McGehee would be the best option to take over third full time this year if Hall is injured, traded, or struggles like he did last year. Lamb and Counsell can be productive as bench players, but not full time. McGehee at least has the potential to be productive full time at third, and he is a good fielder (from what I've read). So like Duffy, let him get his licks down in AAA as a full time player, so if/when he's needed, he can hit the ground running in the majors. Feel free to rip these thoughts to shreds if you must. http://forum.brewerfan.net/images/smilies/wink.gif