1. How about May 15 this year against the Dodgers? 0-0 in the 7th and he gives up 6 runs. We lose 7-2. 2. August 15, 2005 against the Rockies. Brewers down 3-2 in the 7th after the offense just scored a run to make it close, and he gives up 3 runs after pitching great up to that point. We lose 11-2. 3. April 20, 2005 against the Astros. Brewers losing 3-1 in 7th and he gives up 3 runs after pitching great. We lose 6-1. 4. August 12, 2004 against the Braves. 2-2 in the 6th after the offense just tied it up (again, Ben is pitching well), and he gives up the game winning home run. We lost 4-2. 5. April 30, 2004 against the Pirates. Brewers up 1-0 in the 6th and Ben is pitching a gem. He gives up 3 runs and they lose 4-2. I only looked at games where he received a loss and I only focused on the later innings. I do recall other games where he has given runs back the inning after the offense has either taken the lead or tied it up for him, but I don't have the time to research every game he's ever pitched. This is not to try and show that Sheets is a bad pitcher. He is a very good pitcher and has run into a lot of bad luck in his career. But, as an ace pitcher, he seems to have trouble in the later innings with putting a team away. It could very well be fatigue, lack of focus or both. I do think there is such a thing as "toughness" or "grittiness" when it comes to pitching. To me it means digging down and finding that something extra to put away a team or a batter even though the pitcher may be tired or starting to lose focus. Sheets has been able to do this in games that I have watched him pitch, but I tend to lose confidence that he will do it every game. Watching C.C., I get the feeling in every game that he will dominate in those situations and he usually does. I get the same confidence (although unpleasant) watching Zambrano pitch in those situations as well. Call it what you want, but Sheets does not have the consistent mental "toughness" a #1 ace should have in my opinion.