The loss of talent over the past few years (Hader, Burnes, Williams and Adames) makes it so hard. So some of this is on the owner for lack of willingness to invest in at least one star (and I acknowledge the prior attempt with Yelich backfired; and the excellent decision on Chourio last year), but you need to invest in players.
The other part is I do question the front office - I mean last year looked great and the Contreras deal was amazing (that was still when Stearns was in consultant role?). But since then Arnold has whiffed mostly. While Devin is having his own issues in NY, he was considered one of the best closers in baseball, and we got an injured arm (one of those highly paid pitchers who is out for a while; but also one with an arm injury history) and a prospect who does not look fully MLB ready. We kept 40 man roster spaces for Jay, Capra among others instead of a home grown prospect in S. Smith. I will not pretend I knew he would have success at the bigs already, but watching him come up the past 2 years healthy in the minors I was so excited for a Mis-Henderson-Smith-Rodriguez-Wichrowski homegrown AAA rotation that one could dream on for a few years to come in the bigs. Now he is exceeding those expectations. Plus some of the FA signings, where Stearns seemed to jig instead of the collective jag of MLB GMs, and it worked, that approach is less well refined the past 1-2 years, as there are fewer real diamonds in the rough (Megill was picked up in '23; can't recall one since).
Lastly the team has little heart. Adames is not only talented but was the vocal leader when he arrived in '21. Braun was that role from '08 - '19. I don't see that person now. Chourio is young and immensely talented but I don't see him that vocal leader (maybe not yet, maybe to come), and Contreras and Yelich seem the quiet, lead-by-example types. Even the pitchers - Hader and Burnes and Woodruff had that energy. Peralta still does, but the rest not so much.
Anyway, the prospect pool has the talent, and hoping for better things to come, but this year's team lacks that relentless-ness, that heart, and sadly the full complement of talent. Bummer. But let's go Brewers.