I'm not a big fan of so called insiders because they're just not reliable. My issues with Hall come from personal observation. For instance, he turns triples into doubles by not hustling. Last year he started running harder once Branyan came up and finally got his first triple in two years. Early in his career he was a decent base stealer but apparently stopped studying pitchers and/or doing the work required to at least maintain decent numbers. Heck, even Carlos Lee could swipe an occasional base by paying attention to the pitcher's tendencies.