I was thinking about this today, so I'll bump it. Here's what I would do if I were Mr. Melvin: OF (5) Braun, Hart, Morgan, Gomez, Kotsay IF Fielder, Weeks, Betancourt, McGehee, Hairston, Counsell, Green C (2) Lucroy, Kottaras SP (3.5) Greinke, Marcum, Gallardo, Wolf RP (7.5) Axford, K-Rod, Saito, Hawkins, Loe, Estrada, Wolf, Narveson I could go either way with Counsell/Wilson. Because it's the playoffs and back ups won't start many (if any) games, I think I'd rather go with Counsell than Wilson for his defensive abilities.