Schoop has a higher career OPS and OPS+ than Villar. And Villar's career numbers are all propped up by his excellent 2016 season. I won't say definitively that Schoop has been the better hitter but to say Villar has been better is not correct at all. Cause Schoop’s career OPS+ isn’t propped up by his one good season (2017) either. OPS+ Villar, Schoop 2013: 79, 124 (15 PA's) 2014: 75, 65 2015: 109, 111 2016: 117, 98 2017: 72, 122 2018: 91, 90 Career: 93, 99 There's the numbers for all to see. They both have had up and down careers, which is why I said neither is definitively better than the other, and saying Villar has been the better hitter in his career is not true.