Gibson is better than you're making him out to be. He's having a fine season, really has become a strikeout pitcher and improved his slider. He was a top prospect coming up so this breakout season isn't out of nowhere. Obviously he's not DeGrom but for the right price he makes a ton of sense to try to get with Dozier. You are 100% right about my assessment on Gibson. I want the Brewers to make the playoffs but don't want to give up the prospect capital it would take to acquire a #3 pitcher. The Brewers, in my opinion, desperately need to upgrade at TOR SP, 2B, SS and C. I see remedies to 3/4 of those available currently with a trade for Dozier, a call-up of Arcia and, if they are truly made available, a deal for deGrom, Syndergaard or Archer (C is Pina-Nottingham-Kratz-Bandy whether we like it or not). I don't see an innings eater like Gibson as any better than Chacin, Anderson or Guerra. They are very, very solid rotation pieces for the regular season, but nothing that represents a true #1 in the postseason that will their stopper. The Brewers need a TOR SP to compete for a WS and if they don't get that I would prefer they exhaust the in house options of Woodruff, Burnes and Peralta (which gives you 6 SP with the aforementioned 3) rather than dealing for the Gibsons of the world.