Ironically, the prospects that Melvin has traded away in his tenure who turned out to be the best MLB players (recent trades pending) have netted us Tony Graffanino, Kevin Mench, and 1.5 years of a decent closer. I would bet that De La Rosa and Cruz will end up having far more valuable as players then the other 8 guys combined. We'll see though. Odorizzi and Lawrie are the only guys who have a decent shot at being better than average players, and they certianly aren't guarantees. The other 6 guys are very likely to be the kind of guys who are available every off-season. Basically I'd say that the Crew gave up 3 legitimate prospects (LaPorta looked legit at one time; he might put it together to have a good year or two, but that isn't really that valuable at 1B/DH) and 5 filler guys. Meanwhile, one trade got us to the playoffs, the other two have put us in a very good position to be in the playoffs this year and the next. After that, we'll be relying on our drafts from 2009-2011 to have developed. Also, I'm not sure that "That's not good value regardless of the results on the field" really makes sense. I'd say that if we make the playoffs the next two years, the increased revenue and fan fervor for the years to come would more than make up for whatever value we lost by giving up the prospects. A WS championship would certainly justify it as well. It might be riskier in your estimation since these are no guarantees, but your philosophy is no guarantee either.