I strongly agree. It'd be different if Gennett's platoon strength was vs LHP. But a LH hitter who does well vs RHP (career .307/.339 vs RHP, even last year he was .279/.310 vs RHP) and plays fairly decent 2B (overall a positive dWAR score, he's not Brandon Phillips with the glove but he can play the position) has plenty of value. And he's only entering his age 26 season. And he is still playing for league minimum, isn't arby eligible until 2017 and is under team control until 2020. All of those things are very valuable aspects of having him on the roster. The Brewers aren't going to just give him away. Scooter is "young controllable talent". Obviously he'd have more value if he walked more or if he played multiple positions, but just taken for who he is, Scooter is a good player.