Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic

Playing Catch

Verified Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    2,207

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    12

 Content Type 

Profiles

Forums

Blogs

Events

News

2026 Milwaukee Brewers Top Prospects Ranking

Milwaukee Brewers Videos

2022 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks

Milwaukee Brewers Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

Guides & Resources

2023 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks

2024 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks

The Milwaukee Brewers Players Project

2025 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Pick Tracker

2026 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Tracker: Picks & Bonuses

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by Playing Catch

  1. Playing Catch
    I think people are getting a big too excited about Hoskins. He's a huge upgrade from what the Brewers got last year, but he's not, and never has been, an all-star. I think why I, and obviously the majority of posters here, wanted him was simply because it made so much sense for a lower payroll team. If Hoskins was really good, the Brewers never would have been able to sign him in the first place.
  2. Playing Catch
    This is silly to say, I know, but in a weird way, I think it would be easier to replace Burnes than Willy. With a Burnes trade, you'll be able to at least cover his innings using a bunch of guys, perhaps MLB-ready guys that would be part of a strong return. But trading Willy means Turang is the only SS that I can see in the organization that can reasonably be expected to be ready to play in MLB this season. If Turang would get hurt in this scenario, who plays short?
  3. Playing Catch
    I think Brewerfan is just saying that yes, we all know he's a troll. Trolls behave EXACTLY like this. Plan (A) move goalposts, plan (B) make strawman arguments, plan (C) make goalposts out of strawman. Then flame. Always pump the bellows just enough so that posters get mad, but that the mods don't ban you. In terms of the risk of the 2nd year, I think it's acceptable risk. I think we have collective trauma after witnessing some truly horrible seasons the last few years, whether it be JBJ, Cain's last season, Tellez last year. If any of those season were merely poor, rather than dreadful, they wouldn't have been so painful.
  4. Playing Catch
    Would this be enough to make him eligible for the whole, opening-day-roster-rookie-of-the-year benefit?
  5. Playing Catch
    I pretty much hated the Avina/Sanchez trade. For those of you who believe I support every move this FO does, I didn't like this one. And I didn't even like Avina that much!
  6. Playing Catch
    I'm not picking on you, titanrick, but the narrative that guys are "lost for nothing," can't end with, "only a comp pick." Guys are KEPT through, what will possibly be their peak career season... the year before they become free agents, in the middle of their peak. That season of production is VERY hard to get back in a trade, ESPECIALLY, if the return is unproven, albeit top-notch, talent from the minor leagues. If Burnes earns 6 WAR this season, it will be very difficult to recoup that, regardless of the return. Without looking it up (thanks, Sveum!), I'm going to put the CAREER WAR over/under on players that were once top 50 prospects at about 1.5. With this said, I totally disagree with those that believe this means the Brewers are "all-in," and that Burnes/Adames are off the market. I believe this particularly shrewd front office is perfectly capable of pulling an Icarus, and trading Burnes for guys that are MLB-ready AND controllable... #havingonescakeandeatingittoo. EDIT TO ADD: Love the Hoskins signing. Love it. let the kids simmer and cook in AAA.
  7. Playing Catch
    I don't think I'm going to forget the PSU loss anytime soon. I like to think that I do a good job of compartmentalizing my irrational fandom, but the PSU game really, really bugs me. If how I feel is indicative of how the Badgers feel, I think Indiana is in trouble.
  8. Playing Catch
    Refs rewarding aggression on both sides. Let's go get it!
  9. Playing Catch
    "Expected" to win and, "I expect this team to beat PSU tonight." are different to me. Sure the oddsmakers have their favorite, therefore the Badgers are "expected" to win, But if I were a coach or player for the Badgers, and the Badgers lose, they failed to meet expectations, and they should be super disappointed. Likewise, "I expect this team to beat PSU tonight." There would be no viable excuse for losing this game. Champions don't lose games like this. (Unless of course we're talking about the 2014-15 B1G Champion Badgers who lost on the road on January 11th to T-Rank's #184 Rutgers squad).
  10. Playing Catch
    I thought Votto has said he will never leave the Reds. That he would choose retirement. Did I just make that up?
  11. Playing Catch
    I agree with Jay87. I think Clarke is a good bet to have a decent MLB career -- even if it's just a Luke Voit-style RH slugger 1B/DH type of career. Martinez has intrigued me for years. It would be pretty fun if he turned in a 20/20 season this year, and makes for a tough decision for Brewers brass to keep/lose him.
  12. Playing Catch
    Credit to Collins for having them locked in the whole game, my lousy prediction was somewhat based on my belief they'd come in flat, fighting the 11 am start and snow. I also expected that the Badgers would do a better job on the boards, and of course, a better job with ball security. I also expected about 45 free throw attempts.
  13. Playing Catch
    Now THIS is the kind of officiating I hate.
  14. Playing Catch
    That kind of improvement while drafting as a two-time division champ and two-time wild card... I'm not sure what else needs to be said for people that don't believe it's a well-run organization (which requires leadership and investment).
  15. Playing Catch
    So you're saying he could play first base??
  16. Playing Catch
    Speaking for myself, part of the reason I don't mind a little disparity is simply due to the economics of things. The larger markets already subsidize the smaller markets, not just in financial terms, but in bringing eyeballs to ballparks and TVs. (Without doing any research on the topic), I would guess that the vast majority of baseball fans ONLY pay attention to their own team, unlike in the NFL or NBA. I know that once the Brewers are eliminated, my interest in baseball really craters. If MLB wanted NFL-levels of parity, MLB would lose millions and millions of eyeballs (and dollars) because if the Mets and Yankees were as bad as the Jets and the NY Football Giants, it would ultimately impact stadium revenue AND TV revenue in that market. If we were being honest with ourselves about desiring a perfect competitiveness-to-revenue ratio across the league, The Brewers would move to New York to become more financially AND competitively viable. With this said, I believe MLB is nearing that tipping point of competitiveness, and that further rules will need to be added to maintain the current competitiveness of the league.
  17. Playing Catch
    Badgers are going to absolutely crush Northwestern today. 85-60.
  18. Playing Catch
    This is officials' favorite trick, IMO. There's a bunch of dead-ball, non-turnover, non-shooting fouls on one team, and with the same number of fouls called, the other team shoots 20 more free throws.
  19. Playing Catch
    I guess I'd have to watch it again, I just always know going into a B1G road game that the road team is gunna get hosed a few times. I just don't like it when the Badgers get hosed AND they get into foul trouble, or AND there's a big discrepancy in foul shots (when both teams have about the same number of fouls). That's when I feel like the fix is in. The slanted calls/no calls in favor of OSU didn't result in either of these events, so I felt fine. I usually reserve my hatred of refereeing for those games when the Badgers play against an aggressive defense predicated on forcing TOs. It's THOSE games that drive me nuts, because the Badgers will get called for ticky-tack stuff while the aggro-team gets away with murder.
  20. Playing Catch
    Gasser had a hard time getting out of the shadows, too.
  21. Playing Catch
    I'm looking around other game threads... am I the only one that thought this game was officiated really well by a couple of disciplined defenses?
  22. Playing Catch
    Max is awesome, no one has said otherwise. But he's gunna need to continue to take advantage of being the 4th defensive priority for the Badgers to keep winning these games. He's like all of those Purdue guys who are clearly down the pecking order, but end up their 2nd leading scorer. He'll be All-B1G defensive team. Is that enough credit?
  23. Playing Catch
    We, as fans, may need to either just accept that he'll be on the team at least until the deadline, or the Brewers will get back a package that we don't really like.
  24. Playing Catch
    The other thing with Burnes is that the teams that would be trading for him know that there is little hope/expectation that he would sign an extension. I see in all of these team-specific threads on Burnes that it's hard to find an acceptable trade for both sides. In the Yankees thread, for instance, even the fanbases can't find a trade that they both like.
  25. Playing Catch
    I still respect Clancy for these efforts... although if everyone did it, it wouldn't work. When was the first Brewerfan top lists? Like 2004? Toby's Top 40 or something like that? Or does it go back even further?
×
×
  • Create New...