Why exactly can't Pina be the primary starter? He's not the kind of stud All Star you push to catch 150+ games, but I don't see why he can't catch 120. The backup catcher spot is a bigger concern depending on how they are evaluating Nottingham, but fixing that problem does not require us using our free agency resources when SS, 3B, and possibly 1B are bigger needs (1B depend on whether they plan on moving Braun). I'm perfectly fine with upgrading SS, and having Pina be the boring guy on the team who hits 8th and puts up an average to slightly-below-average 1.0-2.0 WAR season. He’s caught over 100 games ONCE in his entire career including the minor leagues. He’s going to be 33-years old and I don’t expect that to change. He wears down back there. He’s good for 85-95 games a year which is why you need a solid platoon mate with him for the catching position to work with Pina.