I don’t understand why or how he’s overrated. His team has improved each year. We were technically supposed to be in rebuild for quite a bit longer. All GMs have moves that dont pan out. All of them. But the one thing you can’t take away from Stearns is that this team is in a much better place today than when he took over and going forward. Don't overlook how Melvin got it started. Melvin acquired Hader/Houser/Santana/Phillips, Davies, Knebel, Diplan, and Lind (who Stearns flipped for Freddy Peralta). I agree. I think what Melvin did in his time as the Brewer GM is very underrated.