The concept of this thread is ridiculous. As if other good teams don't have mediocre or bad players on their rosters. The God of depth and roster construction Billy Beane is carrying Daric Barton, Eric Sogard and Nick Punto. Juan Francisco has been medicore at the plate since his first week in Toronto, and cannot play defense to save his life. Overbay's been crushing the ball for the past month+ and has been a valuable piece. He's a good choice in a PH role late in the game because he can actually work a count and make a guy throw some pitches. Hunter Morris is doing terrible in AAA for the second straight year so I don't even know why anyone brings his name up anymore as a serious option. It's a total baseball cliche at this point for fans to hate their managers and think they're smarter than the GM, but there isn't really much for people to criticize. This is the best defensive team Melvin has ever put together. They've got a couple studs up the middle and solid to above average guys on the corners. Davis has a noodle arm, but Weeks is the only one who's really painful to watch. That's a big part of the reason the pitching has exceeded expectations, and at least for me it makes them a lot less frustrating to watch day in day out. A big part of that is saying 'no thanks' to high power/high strikeout/no glove guys like Francisco, which has been a Melvin weakness in the past. If choosing Overbay over Juan is the worst move Melvin makes in 2014 then he's doing better than most GM's.