He is substantially worse than Thames, actually. Substantially. Despite his time in the OF, Thames has basically been slightly below average in total this year defensively. Davis has played 11 games in the OF and tallied -1.3 WAR out there. In 11 games. Seriously guys, his bat is nice if you have the DH. Otherwise his defense erodes much of his offensive value. dWAR over a 11 game span....come on man. You think he is really worth about -16+ WAR per year defensively? He doesn't even have a single error in his 80 or so innings. That's just impossible to believe he is that bad. Of course maybe things have changed not playing the OF much these days. With us he actually ran good routes and got good jumps (severely underrated and under noticed by novice fans). Was his arm weak? Yah, but that is incredibly overrated by fans constantly. Yelich has a trash arm and no one really bats an eye. With us he was about a -1.0 WAR guy defensively (I would agree there), but that surely was not bad at all with the offense he provided...especially in his last year. Stearns likely thought it was a fluke and sold high. Too bad for us it wasn't and our light trade package turned to junk if Nottingham doesn't provide anything. There is no way Eric Thames is better than Davis in the OF. Eric Thames shuffles and side steps to fly balls in the gap, he can't get grounders without looking like a tumble weed, and looks so uncomfortable you wonder if he thinks he has no clothes on. It is brutal. Nothing is easy for him out there.