The past three years we've been spending $20 million+ on Suppan, Hall and Riske. Where's the value there? Add Hawkins, Davis and Hoffman this year. We've been paying for uselessness for years. If we are going to spend $20-25 million and I'm not sure I want to right now, I'd rather spend it on one elite player than on three crappy players like we have been the past four years. You are assuming we make no further mistakes on signings. That hasn't happened in a long time so I have a problem just assuming that will be the case going forward. Well said. Signing Lee does not mean no one else will be hurt/ineffective, that's the nature of the game. I'm not sure how the argument that all your eggs in one basket is safer anyway, it seems like a bizarro world belief. As others have said, the idea the Yankees won't just pay $5M more than whatever offer the Crew can come up with seems shortsighted. The Yankees paid CC $3M more per year and 2 more seasons. They can do that with Lee too. The Crew's chance is to find players with loyalty that want to play in MIL. Cliff Lee has never played in MIL and probably has no desire to. Ditto for CLE, KC, and so on. Mark A had a true statement the other day when he discussed how players have negotiated with them, went elsewhere, and then put MIL into their no-trade clause. They had no chance. That's exactly how I feel about Lee. The only way to get a guy like that is to sign and/or develop him, like Yo, and have him want to stay. If you replace Lee's '10 stats with the Crew's worst SP, they prevent about 45 more runs, and by resting the 'pen a bit more, you can probably argue it's 50. Using the rule of 10, that's 5 wins...still nowhere near contention, probably about .500. If used wisely, I gotta think you can improve the club more than 5 wins with $25M.