I've seen articles were Arcia's defense (and reputation) are overrated so pick you poison but your statement "but he's got all the tools" to be perhaps the best in the league" is based on what? Swanson and Arcia had 20 errors each, next guy had 12 please elaborate on the tools. Thanks. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wix-5EpqXVo - we can start there on tools. He has plus glove, plus range, plus arm, double plus instincts...he's a natural shortstop that can make every highlight reel play and then some. The E total relates to consistency, which is something he needs to work on for sure. Also relates to him being able to get to balls that many SS wouldn't dream of making a play on...see example above. He's also 22. He'll grow into his position and get more consistent, the Brewers are clearly banking on it. Everybody has a highlight reel and there are a lot of great SS's in the majors. Almost everybody on this team is available in the right deal if the haul is enough. Arcia brings a top line starter and the Brew take a shot at Cozart, problem solved. whether you like Dubon or not he is another option. If people aren't believing the 86-76 I get it but if you do think this team is that good now is exactly the right time to go get a big time starter, depending on the price.