I dont trust Woodruff's shoulder at all. But when hes healthy, none of those other guys have ever been better than him. * If you told me they were all healthy and asked me who would I rather have over the course of a season, it might not be him because I doubt he holds up physically. But if they were all healhty and I was asked who Id want for 1 or 2 innings over 7 games, its Woodruff. Also, hes been such a good Brewer for so long it would be great to get him a ring on the WS roster. But he'd have to be ready physically (currently, longterm doesn't matter for this), we dont need charity roster spots.
* for example:
May and Woodruff both missed 2024 with injuries
Era+ the last 2 seasons
May: 84, 85
Woodruff: 131, 141