"JoeHova wrote: There were plenty of people who were not in love with the deal from the beginning." There were a few...but if you look back when it happened, the vast majority were in favor of the trade, and I think far and away the vast majority of Brewers fans (beyond this forum) think it was a tremendous move for the franchise. Also most of the national press and commentators have said they thought it was the right thing to do, during and after the season. No, you can't run your team based on that (before you jump to that point), but you can't pretend that there was a significant minority against the trade. It was probably only a few posters on this board, and maybe a vocal minority elsewhere. Throwing out other possible trade scenarios well after the fact is also just delving into revisionist fantasy GM stuff which is kind of irrelevant at this point. For all we know it could have taken much more to get Cain than the package that got CC, and again, anything less than CC's performance and we would have missed the playoffs yet again.