Damned if you do, damned if you don't. Obviuousy when you are in extra inning on the road, the home team basically gets 2 AB's to your 1 (including the bottom of teh 9th), and with the pichers having to hit, you only have so many options. I can appreciate the argument that CoCo should have been brought in last night after Balfour allowed a runner or two, (and that the Balfour experiment should be brought to an immediate end), but overall, or on a philosphical level, I do agree with saving your closer in that situation because the home team always gets another AB. Seems silly to be having this discussion though, since that situation never should have happened - on a general level, this topic probably assumes that you have an offense capable of scrating out 1 run, when you have bases loaded with nobody out, along with multiple other opportunites to score a second run in 12 innings! Ned did what he had to do, the offense didn't.