I was just about to start a thread exactly like this. I feel like the McClung/Bush "platoon" was a more of a makeshift way to force Suppan (and his big contract) back into the rotation, than it was really about Brewers management believing that one can't pitch at home and the other can't on the road. I think it's pretty clear that right now, based purely on ability and performance, Suppan should be in long relief. However, when you add salary and past "big-game performances", Suppan is still given the benefit of the doubt. The big thing about Suppan is, he's supposed to be such a workhorse. Well, he's only on pace for 165 innings this year. McClung has averaged more innings/start than Suppan, over each of their last 8 starts. I think the best rotation the Brewers could have right now would be: Sabathia Sheets Parra Bush McClung However, with the uncertainty of the staff next year, the Brewers will almost certainly figure to need Suppan in the rotation during 2009. The probably wouldn't want to upset him by moving him to the bullpen this year.