I'm on the fence about a Halladay trade. On one hand: The Brewers need pitching desperately... and not only for this year, but for next year as well. There is no way they can sign a top of the rotation guy; so to acquire a top of the rotation guy, they need to give up something. And in my opinion, Halladay would REALLY have to hate Milwaukee not to stay because if the Brewers trade for him, he's going to get the Sabathia treatment the rest of the year (sell outs every time he pitches, huge ovations, just lots of love from the fan base). To add to that, he'll be on a competitive team. So if you add Halladay, we will probably have a very similar team next year, starting players and rotation anyways. So you go with that for the rest of this year and next... and then, in my opinion, the end of the road with Fielder comes. Unless he's willing to sign a deal for another couple years, the Brewers HAVE to trade him so they don't just get 2 picks for him. So that will be an opportunity for the team to get some promising prospects at needed positions. On the other hand: Trading top prospects is ALWAYS a huge risk for the Brewers. If we trade for Halladay today and he blows out his arm and needs Tommy John tomorrow, the team is absolutely screwed. It gave up it's future for the present, and now the present is gone. And also the obvious, it gave up cheap players for 1.5 years. I guess at this point, I'd be leaning towards making the trade. As frustrated with Hardy as I am, I don't consider him a .220 hitter and have to think he's going to break out of it. And I think Hart has the potential to raise his average 15-20 points. Thus, I believe our offense will be fine, and improve a bit... but will still be frustrating at times. We play St. Louis 9 times in the last month, so anything is possible. And it would sure help our chances if we could throw Gallardo and Halladay against them 5-6 times in the last month.