I have a tough time grading this offseason in a very positive way. C is being gracious, but I give it a C anyways.
I like the Williams trade and am excited for what Durbin brings long term. And getting more innngs covered, a veteran Sp back for Williams, makes sense too.
Yet, I think the whole Woodruff deal from a year ago hurts us big time now. Why we spent that much last year for Woodruff to maybe be a shell of himself is crazy to me. I hope I am surprised that he is starting games regularly and doing well. I expect him to be hurt and in the bullpen right now, draining 2025 FA dollars elsewhere.
I am not upset at all that Adames is gone. His defense is going down and his offense will not go up… the Brewers are getting out from his contract at just the right time. I fully expect him to bat on average .220 with 20 HRs and below avg defense.
What would make this an A offseason? Maybe trading a few minor league pieces for a top of the rotation starter with 2-4 years of control. Or getting a couple of guys like Turang, Mitchell, or Frelick on Peralta/Lucroy type deals. Or trading for/signing a proven, quality 3B.
The great thing is we still look pretty good on paper without the moves. That gives some hope too that not a lot is need now, and that we can add on in June and July as needs arise and opportunities present themselves at lower cost. Having a C offseason is not big sadness either.