The statcast catch probability metrics have him in the top 10. Good for statcast. I don't believe in any defensive metrics, they are incredibly subjective. I realize eye test is subjective also, but as I watch various MLB games, there's a ton of really good CFers. So I'm not saying Broxton is horrible, it's just that by the standard today, Broxton is not anything more than average. I've seen him botch way too many plays that the really good MLB CFers make. Just my opinion, I realize I'm alone on a limb. One thing the eye test probably isn't telling you, at least not clearly, is how many plays that a CFer like Nieuwenhuis for instance might make a great diving play on, on a play that Broxton would have run down easily and made look routine.