His BABIP was only .277 last year, so he was incredibly unlucky. RBI's are a function of number of runners on in front of you, not in your own performance. I could see him, very easily, hitting 2nd or 3rd in the Brewers lineup, if he put up that .400 OBP in the majors. Using the 'standard formula' BABIP ~ LD% + .120 (his LD% was 19%) his BABIP should've been about .310, which would've bumped his average into the .275-280 range. As for, why give up something for him now... if he can be had on the cheap, the question is, why not? He'd be a better PH than Inglett, and a guy who could step in for Prince if Fielder is moved this season.