Kenny Lofton had a career OPS+ of 107, where as Raines was 123, that's really not even close. That's Casey McGeehee to Corey Hart last year. Those years, "After '87" when he was "Virtually done" he still put up an OPS+ of 115, higher than Lofton's career number. They really aren't close on the offensive side of the ball. Oh, and after '87, Dawson's OPS+: 114. Was Dawson great and a force of nature before he got hurt? Sure, he was. But, he got hurt. Lots of guys get hurt all the time. Should Francisco Liriano be a hall of famer? He was unbelievable before he got hurt. It's a sham that Dawson is in, and Blyleven, Alomar, Trammel and Raines are all on the outside looking in.