I think the MVP should go to the offensive player with the best raw numbers. By my criteria, Kemp deserves it. Fielder should be #2. Kemp's OPS is essentially the same as Prince, but Kemp gets the nod for stealing 22 bases in 25 attempts, compared to Prince's 0 for 0. Prince also contributes nothing on defense. If you disqualify Kemp because the Dodgers stink, then it should go to Prince. McCann is the best catcher but I put him in the 5-6 range behind Braun, Votto, and maybe Berkman.