Put it this way... I'd see no problem with signing Kendall to a four-year extension, provided it doesn't break the bank (say $9 million over four years). I wouldn't sign Kendall. As pointed out already, Kendall is going to get ~$4.5M next year -- and he deserves it -- however his offensive production is below average and while I am entirely grateful he is our catcher over Estrada -- there are probably going to be better options in 2010. If Kendall wants to be a backup for a couple of years -- I am all for that. To me, it is a no-brainer, Seth McClung is our unsung hero. He has pitched well (relatively speaking) in every place that the Brewers have put him in, bullpen or rotation. He definitely allowed the Brewers to tread water and stepped up his game. If the Brewers maintain 1st place and they start getting more national attention, I suspect Seth's effort will be overlooked for the most part.