I don't care how old he is, just that there's a reason he hasn't done anything in the majors before last year (hmmm, not very good?) Again -- see his injury history. If we go with the what have they proven method than I'm thinking Hall shouldn't be at third (80 some games in the bigs there), we can't count on Braun, Yo, or Parra (less than one season in the bigs), Weeks or Hardy (have had injury histories), Cameron, Turnbow, or Gagne (Peds issues), Kapler (hasn't played in the bigs for a few years), etc. There's no way this would be fair by any stretch of the imagination. The real question is...what didn't Dillon do last year to prove himself?