Yes, his walk rate is low. But most of his career has been in the 8 spot, where you need to be more aggressive at the plate with the pitchers spot behind you. Lucroy is a very good hitter, and would adjust to the 2 spot. I have no doubt he would realize with Braun behind him, he needs to take more walks. He has 26 walks in 497 PAs when batting somewhere in the order other than 8th. That is a BB% of 5.2%. That's what I heard last year when McGehee was struggling. Turned out the trend was a much better indicator than career numbers. McGehee never showed any signs of being a productive player in the minors. He came up to the Majors and had a great season or two that was unexpected. Weeks has much more talent and much better tools and has been a plus performer for longer than McGehee (3 straight seasons of an OPS+ over 120 for Weeks. Yes one of those seasons was cut very short due to an injury). I will always assume a player is likely to perform closer to career numbers than over any individual 20 games. On top of all this, I'm sure someone on this site could find an article stating that batting order has very little effect on runs scored by a team. If we want to start talking about the ideal batting order, let's start with the pitcher batting 8th and someone like Weeks/Lucroy/Segura batting 9th.