McClouth, a star? :Sigh: This is why I think it is silly to reward All-Star berths on statistics. Especially only statistics from half a season. Nate McClouth, a star? Really? See here's the deal, for me personally. I am going to shell out hundreds of dollars to attend an All-Star Game, I do not want to see Nate McClouth roaming the outfield over Ryan Braun. And that's not, as it seems to be claimed, through homer-tinted goggles. Ask 90% of baseball fans all over America and I'm sure the answer to the questions, Who is the Star? , Who do you want to watch play?, and the answer is Ryan Braun. The All-Star Game should be a reflection of fan popularity and star appeal mixed with quantifiable results. (For Example, Pujols should not make the game if he tears his leg off in Game #1 and sits the DL all year). Simply because a player has a nicer OBP over the previous 80 games should not be an argument for making the All-Star Game. If I were a Pirates Fan, I don't think I could look at myself in the mirror with a straight face and claim, I'm gonna go buy a pair of tickets to the Pirates game tonight because I want to watch Nate McClouth roam the outfield. If Pirates fans can't even say that, why should the Baseball Nation as a whole want to watch him in a game designed to bring out the stars?