Why do you say that? There aren't other minor league options? Or a trade or free agent signing wouldn't be possible to fill either 3B or SS? I am not crazy about trading either one, but if you can trade one (not both) and get back a pitcher like Roy Halladay that you can make a run with this season and next, I think you have to do it. I agree with you Invader. One would definitely be a part of the deal and I believe Lawrie would be as well. The only way the Brewers may get out of giving up two of the three prospects is if they add a big salary (Rolen, Rios) and work that out. A little birdie has confirmed to me that the Brewers are legit in this deal. However, as KR mentioned, Halladay may not want to be Brewer. If he dropped his no-trade clause and became a Brewer, it would be right at the deadline because Halladay wants to see all his options out there. I believe the Brewers would fall behind the Phillies, Dodgers, etc in Halladay's mind and he wouldn't want to commit too early.