With all the talk of bullpen misuse and starters not going deep enough into games, I thought I would look up some information on bullpen usage from last year and this year. To set up the discussion, it was late July 2007, when Doug Melvin made a move to bring in Scott Linebrink with hopes to improve the Brewers beleagured bullpen and thus help the Crew push toward their first playoff birth in 25 years. Ultimately as many of us want to forget, the Derrick Turnbow's, Chris Spurlings, Matt Wise's, and even Linebrink and Cordero wore down in the second half and the Brewers fell two games short of the Cubs. Or did the relievers really wear down? Here is the list by National League Team of total innings thrown by the bullpens in ALL of 2007. The Brewers ranked 11th of all National League teams for innings pitched for the bullpen arms. (Caveat- anyone with a paid membership to baseball-reference.com can get these stats just to the All-Star Break from 2007). Here is the roster of Brewer relievers that accounted for all the bullpen innings in 2007. With all of that stats that are posted there, I think it just came down to the fact the Ned Yost just didn't have the horses to get the job done down the stretch. In high leverage situations last year he basically used Turnbow,Wise, Spurling, Shouse, and Linebrink to get to Cordero in 2007. There wasn't a lot of quality there. It could be argued that Turnbow was effective earlier in the season and he did get overused by Yost, but considering Turnbow was DFA'd in early 2008 it suggests that he just wasn't a quality trustworthy arm. I think when looking at 2007, I don't know that it was completely fair to say that the bullpen was abused when looking at the total innings pitched in 2007. I think the bullpen failed because collectively they were not very good. Old news. Now fast forwarding to 2008. As non-Ned Yost supporters might ask, Has Ned Yost learned his lesson in regards to bullpen misuse and abuse of relievers? Here is the list by National League team of total innings thrown by the bullpen this year (All-Star Break). The Brewers rank 15th of 16 teams in total innings pitched suggesting that the starters are going deeper this year either by Ned Yost forcing the issue by keeping the starters in for an inning or more this year than last or just plain and simply the starters are better in 08 than 07. Here is the list of Brewers relievers that have accounted for those innings in 2008. The problem that I see again in 2008 is the same in 2007 regardless of the fact that the Brewers relievers have thrown the second fewest innings of all teams in the NL. We have too much of Mota which equals the 2007 Turnbow. On the positive side, we have better relievers in Villy and Riske to replace Wise and Spurling which should bear out better results. Obviously we need to replace Mota. I guess, I hear and get caught up in a lot of friendly discussions about bullpen abuse throughout the course of the season. While I don't agree with Ned on a lot of his bullpen decisions, (Sheets start in Colorado game in Colorado), I think the "bullpen innings thrown abuse metric", can be quite overblown as a whole. It still comes down to quality relievers getting the job done. Now you may convince me otherwise if Marmol burns out completely down in Chicago, because he "seems" way overused, but even as a team the Cubs don't have too many innings in them either. (There I go contradicting myself!!!)