Medium contact is not hard contact and that batted ball profile isn't that far off from what Corey Kluber and Carlos Carrasco have done this season. It was a fun story for a former Brewer. It doesn't have to mean "anything" for it to still be a cool little story. Nobody is saying he's the next big star or anything. Not everything has to be critiqued down to the littlest detail. I said he gave up hard contact I didn't reference hard contact% in my first post, the two are not the same thing. I wasn't specifically referring to how one site happens to categorize something which is completely different than how many other sites do. Those are also guys who K 1 per 9, if you aren't striking anyone out you have to either induce a ton of soft contact or keep the ball on the ground. He had a sub 10% soft contact, Kluber is at 15% for the year and 18.7% for his career, Carrasco is at 14.8 and 17.1. Those are not close to each other at all. Other than the fact every single thing you said wasn't true it is a really good comparison though. And you are again sucking the fun out of everything because you have to overanalyze every single thing instead of just acknowledging that it was a really cool moment for a former Brewer. But yes it was so far off, like the 40% hard contact rate that Carrasco gives up compared to the 33% rate Lopez gave up in this game. Again, it's a cool moment for a young pitcher who happens to be a former Brewer. It doesn't need to be analyzed beyond "hey, that's kinda cool, good for him."