'A Harder Way to Score': Pat Murphy's Philosophy of Offense and the 2024 Brewers

[Matthew Trueblood]

In today's game, most teams value power above all other offensive skills. Under Pat Murphy, the Milwaukee Brewers will continue to be an exception to that rule.

Image courtesy of © Joe Camporeale-USA TODAY Sports

Last year, the Brewers were 24th in home runs and 28th in isolated power. They also ranked 24th in team DRC+, according to Baseball Prospectus. Yet, they were 17th in runs per game, marking just one way that the whole was greater than the sum of the parts for them in a division-winning campaign. They drew walks at the third-highest rate in the league, fueling an unconventional offensive engine for MLB in the 2020s.

Isolated power explained roughly 74 percent of the variance between teams in runs per game in 2023, and as you can see, the Brewers were one of the larger outliers in that regard.

It's no secret that power has become more indispensable over the last several years, but to illustrate the magnitude of that change, ISO only explained about 57 percent of variance in runs per game in 2015. In 2000, it was 46 percent. Power has become synonymous with offense.

Not so in Milwaukee, under the integrated, team-focused stewardship of Pat Murphy, Rickie Weeks, Connor Dawson, and Ozzie Timmons. Power wasn't how the Brewers tried to score runs last year, and it won't be how they go about it this year, either.

Andruw Monasterio and Brice Turang had total power outages down the stretch in 2023. Each of them came to camp this spring considerably bigger and stronger. Does Murphy anticipate them trading a bit of contact to find more pop?

"I hope not," the skipper said Wednesday. "I don’t believe in that. I believe home runs are thrown, to a great extent. When you’re trying to do damage, is really when it’s damaging to the club. I look at plenty of players when they’re coming up, ‘Hey, you’ve gotta hit homers, man, you’ve gotta hit homers.’ As soon as you start thinking that…"

Finishing the sentence isn't necessary. The point is made. Murphy doesn't want his hitters to go looking for power; he believes they just need to hit their pitch when it comes. Part of his persistent efforts to share the stories of everyone in the clubhouse this spring and knit the roster together more tightly is his conviction that the game needs to be played with a team mindset.

"It’s a harder way to score. Yeah. Because you’ve gotta pass the baton," Murphy said, but not by way of bemoaning it. "When the 3-2 pitch is eight inches outside, you gotta turn it over to the next guy. Trust the guy behind you: it’s the key to hitting. It’s the key to our offense. Trust the guy behind you. It’s hard to do, when you’re trying to earn your keep and you get a 3-2 breaking ball in the dirt, but you were hoping it would be out over the plate, well you think, ‘Maybe I can still make contact.’ You have to be willing to pass the baton."

As the walk rate from 2023 reflects, the Brewers have been good at that under the leadership of Dawson and Timmons, anyway. Murphy, of course, has been part of those conversations all along, and he expects to carry forward that mentality as the manager.

Trusting teammates means more than just taking the borderline pitch in a deep count. It also means using the opposite field, where appropriate, sacrificing some opportunity to split a gap or clear the fence for an increased likelihood of getting on base. It can mean stopping oneself from getting thrown out ill-advisedly on the bases, too. Murphy has expressed a desire to be aggressive and make plays with speed, but he also wants to see his team avoid making bad outs. Believing that the next guy will get you over or in to score can help with that.

Yes, it also means bunting. Murphy is not going to resuscitate the dying sacrifice bunt, but that doesn't mean it won't be part of the team's repertoire of offensive moves.

"Sal Frelick can bunt--and should, because he hits so many balls to the left side, so [bunting] forces those guys into a bad spot," Murphy said. Before the infield shift was banned, the bunt was a more obvious means of pulling a defense out of its preferred shape. Now, it might not seem as necessary, and the hits to be gained directly by the bunt are not as easy to get, but the effect of forcing a team to set itself differently remains in play.

"Bunting is misunderstood in the game. It's not always for the percentages," said Murphy. "It's sometimes for the momentum. Think about the qualities of beating a No. 1, beating a star, beating a dude. Scherzer. How do you beat Scherzer? Sometimes there's little things that you can do that just drive them mad, that you didn't have to execute a perfect swing on a great pitch. It ends up disrupting them a little bit. So it's worth practicing, if you can break down a No. 1 just a hair."

That's a good encapsulation of Murphy's offensive philosophy. He attends to details. He believes in a team approach, and in passing the baton. He doesn't want to merely bludgeon middling pitchers; the plan is to find ways to beat everyone the team faces. It's possible to distill things even further, though. Murphy did that Tuesday.

"Get to first, go left, hurry back."

View full article

[Bratwithspecialsauce]

Great article and music to my ears. I have hoped Murphy would let guys do what they're good at.. instead of preaching launch angles to excellent line drive hitters. I also firmly agree with his philosophy that used in the right situations (like his Scherzer example),  bunting can be disruptive for the pitcher and defense.

I think Frelick and Turang can drive opposing defenses mad if allowed to..

The only thing I'd point out in the article was the seismic shift in production when Willy was moved down to 6th in the order and Tellez got hurt and Canha and Santana replaced them higher in the order.  

Their patience and willingness to walk turned the offense around.

They went from bottom of the barrel in the first half to midpack in offense. 

The right approach (which CC didn't embrace) will win a lot of games. 

[Kripes - Brewers]

I think this is old school baseball, and certainly refreshing to hear. With this lineup, he doesn't really have much choice. If you don't have the power (Turang, Frelick, Miller, Monasterio, Dunn, Capra, Ortiz), you've got to maximize your on-base capabilities with solid contact and pitch selection combined with baserunning skills and speed. We'll never know what really caused Hiura's issues - coming up the dude was a doubles machine/line drive hitter, but it sure seems like he tried to go after that launch angle craze and just lost it. I really think Adames gets a little too focused on the homers too, and I think he would benefit from chilling out and reading this article daily before every game. We hear all the time that "hitting it where they ain't" is really hard with pitchers throwing 95mph+, and I don't doubt that. However, you can at least tell if a guy is thinking about finding the obvious gap and hits a worm burner to that general vicinity versus simply swinging out of his shoes - that batter is being selfish and not staying within himself and using the team approach that Murph is preaching here.  I'll be watching for that early this year to see if the guys are listening. Go Crew!

[Brock Beauchamp]

2 minutes ago, Kripes - Brewers said:

I think this is old school baseball, and certainly refreshing to hear. With this lineup, he doesn't really have much choice. If you don't have the power (Turang, Frelick, Miller, Monasterio, Dunn, Capra, Ortiz), you've got to maximize your on-base capabilities with solid contact and pitch selection combined with baserunning skills and speed. We'll never know what really caused Hiura's issues - coming up the dude was a doubles machine/line drive hitter, but it sure seems like he tried to go after that launch angle craze and just lost it. I really think Adames gets a little too focused on the homers too, and I think he would benefit from chilling out and reading this article daily before every game. We hear all the time that "hitting it where they ain't" is really hard with pitchers throwing 95mph+, and I don't doubt that. However, you can at least tell if a guy is thinking about finding the obvious gap and hits a worm burner to that general vicinity versus simply swinging out of his shoes - that batter is being selfish and not staying within himself and using the team approach that Murph is preaching here.  I'll be watching for that early this year to see if the guys are listening. Go Crew!

Welcome to Brewer Fanatic!

[MJLiverock]

Notice the Brewers were pretty much the worst on this metric in comparison to the playoff teams of a year ago.    Even though the r/g outperformed the regression line vs. ISO, the playoff teams pretty much all did but at a higher r/g rate.  

I don't feel the excitement or see the upside of some earlier posts here -- sure it makes sense to try to maximize the skills of the players but if those skills are limited to begin with - -i.e. no power and low runs per game it doesn't translate to a lot wins if elite pitching isn't coming alongside it to limit runs given up.  There is no trophy for best r/g vs. ISO, all that matters is scoring runs and this article seems to point out how difficult the Brewers had it last year and going forward.  Now that pitching is weakened it is hard to see the excitement of a marginally better offense from what wasn't all that great a year ago.  

[Bratwithspecialsauce]

Yeli, Hoskins, Contreras, Chourio and Adames are all 20-30 HR potential guys, so there's a great mix of speed and pop there.

 Frelick has gap power..

If the speed guys take their walks, this offense will score.

Far more concerned about the starting pitching..Lots of promise, but as it stands I see a lot of 7-5 games