X -- No, Inman wasn't going to help in 2007. However, we found out the hard way that Thatcher was likely capable of contributing what Linebrink did. Thats what we're reducing the work of Jack Z, the true savior of the franchise, to. Luck? As I showed earlier, its almost routine that he selects a quality player with picks this early. Obviously we all love Gollardo, and I know you are extremely high on Hardy. To think 1 of these 2 selections will be a stud, and the other a decent player, is just being realistic based on history. No need for luck here http://forum.brewerfan.net/images/smilies/smile.gif We couldn't agree more on Zduriencik's acumen, but honestly -- yes, it does come a lot down to good luck... even with a very gifted scouting director. The problem as...others have noted going all the way back to the trade forum last year I want to emphasise the "others" part. At the time, I was really geeked about getting Linebrink, mostly because I didn't do my due diligence in checking up on him. This trade, however, taught me quite a bit about trade value of RPs. I think Garrison + Thatcher would have been a fair price for Linebrink.