I will agree to disagree on the dues paying issue. This is his third organization in the past three years. All jobs have been in an administrative role. Has he ever gotten his hands dirty with demonstrable results in player development? I keep hearing how smart he is, but I haven't heard any specific example. Simply put, I think that Attanasio sees him as a protege. Hopefully, he doesn't turn out to be a yes man. I'm also not sure that I like hearing how Melvin will be serving as a mentor due to the lack of experience. It sounds to me like turnover is going to be minimal. If you ask me, this organization needs a major shakeup in the front office. In particular, I think the entire scouting/player development department needs to be blown up. If that doesn't happen, they are just rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic as far as I am concerned. Again, hopefully I am wrong. He might start to win me over if I see members of the old boys club (Ash, Nichols, .etc) being shown the door.