Logan, I've already looked at him somewhat objectively. Some people choose to just shout, "MLE!! MLE!!!", but as we've seen with McGehee so far MLE's aren't exactly gospel. Nobody says they are gospel. They are just a best guess and in my opinion usually a little low. That said, Katin has some pretty ugly OBP's outside of this year if you even take only a little bit off for going up a level. That by itself is enough for me to question bringing him up. He's gotten his OBP up to over .380, he's athletic enough to have 10 total triples over 2008 and 2009 - only one less than Escobar over those two years - and he has a plus arm. These are just additional stats to support the argument. For half a season he has had a very good OBP. That is still a very small sample especially considering it is his third go around in AAA. It isn't like he is a 23 year old in his first year of AAA following up a good year in AA. It looks like he has been a full time player. All players typically hit worse as part time players. He would also be moving up a level. To think he would contribute much of anything this year seems really optimistic to me. Triples have more to do with outfielders misplaying balls than actual talent. Oveall I see a much stronger argument against him being successful than for. I don't think he would be better than either Edmonds or Gerut so as long as we have those 2 guys I really see no place for Katin.