why move Gamel to 3b when McGehee is already there? isn't that like replaceing McGehee with McGehee? why not let Gamel play 1st and then you've only got one guy learning a new position instead of two? (maybe that's slightly off-topic, though, when this is more about personnel and not positions.) Gamel is at 3B and has been since we drafted him. Gamel hit almost as well in his sporadic playing time last year as McGehee has this year and I think will hit in the .850+ OPS range with at least a .340 OBP. That lineup wouldn't be to bad. Gamel probably mostly replaces Hart's production. Cain, well, I don't see how he could possibly be a worse hitter than Gomez and no Edmonds doesn't bring up our CF offense much.(.283/.381/.664, that is OBP/SLG/OPS NOT BA/OBP/SLG) Lawrie seems to has an above average bat somewhat mitigating the loss of Fielder.