I would be willing to bet if Graffy is not hurt, both get taken out. I would also be willing to bet that if Dillon shows he can play 3B with any amount of credability both get taken out as well. Our lack of a 2nd true IF on the bench is hurting us right now. Weeks has had a bad couple of games lately. While he isn't a strong defender, he is still better than Braun. I agree. You actually helped me show what I wanted to. There are many different ways to look at different situations. You can bring up and use stats to support almost any decision you make. If you want a big inning then bunting in that situation would be bad. If you are playing for one run then it is a good move. I know there are also certain thresholds at which a manager should or shouldn't have a player bunt. For the most part only pitchers fall below those thresholds, but if you only look at the % of times 1 run scores, then a bunt makes sense. Like Bucky has been saying, shades of grey.