I think Melvin has done a fine job so far, and I agree with the point that '08 and '09 will be most telling in what he has accomplished. In my opinion, anything this year was going to be gravy as I thought and still think '08 will be our first season where we can be truly disappointed if they aren't in playoff contention nearing the end of the season. He's taken an atrocious Major League roster from when he got here and turned it into a core of guys he had a hand in drafting. Let's not forget, they are still in their early 20's, and relatively speaking didn't spend all that much time in the Minors, so the learning curve extended into the Majors. As for signings, I think the Suppan deal will prove to be his worst. At the time I think alot, if not most, people liked it just because alot of people only really heard of him from the postseason last year. Another part of me says it was a signing that was made just to be made, for some reason we had to pick up someone with a "big name," even though he was only really a big name because he played a big part in the Cardinals postseason. The Hall signing makes me somewhat nervous...I can't say it was a bad thing to do to lock him up for 4yr/24mil, after the year he had last year. If Doug felt Hall could produce 35hr/85rbi every year, I would say we got a bargain based on what Doug was hoping for. I do think Billy will have a much better '08 than '07, but if I had to guess I would say 25hr/70-80rbi/.275ish, in which case I still think we got a good deal on Hall based on the going rate. My guess would be Doug will be around atleast through '09. I think the number one thing a GM in Milwaukee can do is make the minor league system the best it can be. It's the only route to sustained success for a team that just can't buy pieces every year. The other component is simply not being wrong in veteran dealings, which is a hell of a burden to bear when other teams can literally afford to be wrong sometimes. Exactly, even if it means a few years of decent seasons then losing guys, then doing it all over again, it pretty much is the only way it can work.