You know what's funny. If he puts in Cedeno and Cedono gives up the hit (like Jennings did so many times) a chunk of posters would be ripping it saying Peralta was rolling well, why not just let him go. Of course not saying the same folks would've said it, but CC can't win with everybody unless he learns how to magically predict which reliever is gonna give up hits on a given day I disagree. Based on how the game was started, it would have made total sense to stick with it, and not allow Carp to face a righty. For whatever reason, that plan was abandoned, and the decision made failed. Had Peralta gotten him out, you may be right, no one would have said a thing, but he didn't, and this is what we have.