"Baseballreference.com WAR stats" I have no idea what BR is doing to get that. Alcides has better baserunning stats, sure, but not enough to counteract the improvement in SLG for Betancourt. They must not use wOBA. Betancourt is clearly the superior hitter, but only because he can hit for more power. They get on base at about the same clip. Escobar, however, is leaps and bounds better at defense, and I would take him in any season (last year, this year, and for the rest of his career) over Betancourt. Remember, this discussion isn't about Greinke, just Escobar and Betancourt.