About the only time Hall has looked shakey was in that SF series. I will agree with you there. But that ball against the Reds was a bounding ball with a ton of top spin which made it a very difficult play. It was do or die. I have watched every game and Hall has been spectacular. Off balance throws, bare handing dribblers, bad hops, snares, you name it. He has yet to commit an error and we are 14 games in at one of the toughest defensive positions in baseball. He has looked so much quicker too. All I can say is if he keeps playing like this you will see what I am talking about sooner or later. At the same time, you can't really go wrong with Counsell as he is about as consistent as they come.