There's one season that says he's average in RF and people keep saying the numbers are skewed because he's been asked to play in CF. He played 12 games in CF last year, and hadn't played in CF previously since 2013. The narrative that playing CF has skewed the numbers is pretty false. He's played 45 games, TOTAL, in his career. If people want to argue that recently he's been reasonably average in the OF, that's plausible, but again, the CF numbers are so miniscule that they're not really skewing the numbers. I'll say this. I was responding to JMB who asked "why is this guy getting compared to Domingo Santana?" He's got a pretty hefty sample that says he's not a great fielder. He's an average-ish hitter for a corner outfielder, and he's not a great fielder. He's not an absolute butcher in the field, like Santana is, but I can see why people would make the comparison. The difference is (IMO) that Santana at this point has enough of a sample now that pretty much says he should only DH. Garcia is average enough that (as I previously stated) if he's even -5 for a season in a corner, he's not really hurting a team with his defense, as I'd consider that 'average'.