I suspect (heck, not even suspect, but *know*) that there were managers who knew what sabremetrics were before Sabremetrics was a word. Not directing this at you Casey, but quoting your post since your post is most relevant. Max Bishop was not a good hitter But he WAS good at getting on base. http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/split.cgi?id=bishoma01&year=Career&t=b http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/b/bishoma01.shtml He hit almost exclusively leadoff in his career, in the 20's and 30's, despite sometimes hitting in the .240's and .250's. Connie Mack probably knew the value of walking 100+ times a year, even if OBP wasn't a "thing", I'm sure. To go off on a tangent, I know people say managers don't make that big of a difference in W's and L's, but I'm willing to bet that kind of forward thinking can make a few W's show up at the end of a season when you're not tied to stodgy ideals like "put the fastest guy first"