The thing about saying that "this team isn't world series caliber, even if they make the playoffs" is that it's a loaded statement. Let's just say that once the playoffs start, everyone has an equal chance. You still have an 87.5% chance of being right that a given team isn't going to win it all. Recently, the 83 win Cardinals won the world series. The 2007 Rockies were playing .500 ball until about the beginning of September. Last years Rangers were not exactly a great team. The Brewers are on pace for 85 wins. If they win 2 or 3 in a row, that's suddenly on pace for 90. If they lose 2-3 in a row, they'll be on pace for about 82-83 wins. Selling at this point, I'm sorry, it's just a terrible idea. Weeks, Hart, Braun, and Gallardo are locked up long term. There's plenty of money available to offer long term deals to Marcum and Greinke. Lucroy is under team control for at least 4 more years. Even without Fielder, there's still a strong core, and selling off at this point completely undermines the efforts of locking up those core players to long term deals. You don't go long term if you're not in the 'contend' portion of the success cycle, which is where the Brewers are. You can say that the Brewers are an 'average at best team without Fielder', but that's not a quantifiable statement. You're not replacing Fielder with a known quanitity. SOMEONE has to play first base, and I'm assuming that person will have stats, of some variety, that are measurable. Taking the statements "the Brewers are in first place/The Brewers are NOT in first place" both out of the equation, the truth is, the Brewers are in a playoff race. That's not even arguable. They are in a 3, maybe 4 team race for the central division. Pissing that chance away will do nothing but completely alienate the casual fan base that have shown up in the past 5 + years in droves. There will be no upper swing to the success cycle when they're not bringing in nearly 3 million per, which is almost a guarantee if they do a sell-off in a year in which they are legitimately contending. Whether anyone THINKS they are good enough or not is up to debate. What's NOT up to debate is that right now, despite the shortcomings, the Brewers ARE in a playoff race. That's a true and known fact. Selling now will be a huge slap in the face to the fans. I'd also like to know, if selling is so important to the success cycle, who is the last prospect the Brewers traded for that turned out to be a key piece of a winning team? Because honestly, right now, I'm coming up empty on that one. Keep your guys. Compete. Get the comp picks if they walk.