I live in Madison, so that may not help, retail-wise. I like to hit Knuckleheads on State St. when I'm downtown. A decent selection and a large walk-in humidor. Only drawback is I have to be downtown to go there. I have ordered cigars online a few times, as does my Dad, and have had very good results. Thompson Cigar out of Tampa always has a great selection in their catalogs including bundles and package deals. They almost always have some sort of cigar deal that includes a cherry tabletop humidor (Which is what I have), and is perfect for holding 10-15 cigars in a single row. I have different levels of favorites regarding price and sometimes I will try something new based on appearance/price, etc. My favorites are Macanudo, Cohiba, Rocky Patel, Fuente and Punch. I would prefer Cohiba all the time, but they are quite pricey. For example, they have This sampler for $49. It includes 25 cigars and the same humidor I linked above, which they sell on its own for $30.